The Remnant according to the Election of Grace (Rom. 11:1-6)

Elijah Challenging the Prophets of Baal, from a third century A.D. synagogue.
God has a plan for the Jewish people. It is not just a past plan that evaporated with the destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70. It is yet future. For what we will see as we go through this chapter is that God is going to bring about a national conversion of the Jews to Christ. This is what Paul is driving at in verse 26 when he writes, “And so all Israel shall be saved.”
Recall that chapters 9-11 deal with the issue of the Jewish people, especially in light of their widespread rejection of Jesus as the Messiah. We’ve seen that Paul has argued that this does not mean that God has been unfaithful to his promises to Abraham, but rather that he is actually fulfilling his purposes, that Gentile inclusion and Jewish unbelief were both predicted in the Old Testament Scriptures. We’ve noted that in chapter 9 as part of his answer to the charge that God is unfaithful in his promises to Israel, Paul explains the saving promises of God in terms of God’s sovereign election, not in terms of physical descent. But at the end of chapter 9 and on through chapter 10, Paul goes on to explain that the blame for the unbelief of the Jews falls squarely on their own shoulders. God cannot be blamed when they have heard the gospel and rejected it. It is their own fault that they are now outside the church, the new people of God.
However, the apostle is not content to leave it there. The argument of this chapter is that, despite present (in Paul’s day) widespread unbelief among the Jews, God is not finished with them. There is yet a wonderful chapter to be written in which Israel will believe and enter the church. Now, most Jews do not believe the gospel, but there is coming a day when the opposite will be true.
And Paul wants us who are Gentiles to know this. “I speak to you Gentiles,” Paul writes (13). He goes on, “Boast not against the branches” (18); that is, Gentiles are to take note of what God has done and is doing with Israel in such a way that they do not become prideful in comparing themselves with them. He explains, “For I would not, brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits; that blindness in part is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the Gentiles be come in” (25). This is something that we need to know.
So this is what the apostle is doing in this chapter. Chapters 9-10 deal with Israel’s past and present. But chapter 11 deals with Israel’s future.
The chapter is divided into three parts: Inquiry (1-15), Analogy (16-32), and Doxology (33-36). In the first part of this chapter, the apostle asks and answers three questions (1, 7, 11). He is dealing with the apostasy of Israel and what that means (and does not mean) for the future. Then, in the next section, he introduces an analogy of the tree and its branches, some being cut off and some being grafted in, and he interprets and applies this analogy to the Jews (cut off) and the Gentiles (grafted in). The upshot of it is that what has happened to the Jews can also happen to the Gentiles, and vice versa. There are lessons here, and the primary one is humility over presumption. Finally, Paul ends this chapter with one of the most wonderful doxologies in the New Testament. It is not only a fitting summary for this chapter, but it is really the inevitable response of the heart to the entire argument that the apostle has been making up to this point.
As we begin today, I want us to consider the first six verses, which are about the believing remnant among the Jews both past and present. Paul is dealing with the first question, in verse 1, which is, “I say then, Hath God cast away his people?” Is he done with them? In particular, is God’s rejection of Israel total? And his answer is, “God forbid,” or, more accurately, “May it never be!” The apostle then gives three arguments for his answer: one from person of Paul himself (1), and one from the nature of God’s purpose with regard to Israel (2a), and one from the past history of Israel (2b-6).
Now, it’s important for us to see here right from the start that when Paul uses the term “Israel” in chapter 11, he is referring to ethnic Israel. He is not talking about the church which is composed of both Jew and Gentile. It is true that the church is the inheritor of many blessings and promises of the Old Testament. The New Covenant was promised to Israel and Judah, but the NT makes it clear that all believers inherit the blessings of the New Covenant. The church is the New Covenant community. The Lord’s Supper is the New Covenant meal. Baptism is the sign of the New Covenant. Every believer is a son or daughter of Abraham, an argument that Paul makes in this letter in chapter 4 and especially in his letter to the Galatians. In fact, in Gal. 6, when Paul uses this phrase, “the Israel of God,” I think he is probably referring there to the church. The church is the new Israel. The church is the one people of God on the earth.
But we don’t have to then run to the extreme, as some do, and think that God is done with ethnic Israel, or that there is no place for ethnic Israel in terms of the future story of God’s redemptive purposes. That is clearly not the case, as Paul is going to show us here. In this chapter, “Israel” is consistently compared and contrasted with the Gentiles, showing us that it is genuinely ethnic Israel under consideration here. Notice the following verses:
“I say then, Have they stumbled that they [Israel] should fall? God forbid: but rather through their fall salvation is come unto the Gentiles, for to provoke them to jealousy. Now if the fall of them [Israel] be the riches of the world, and the diminishing of them the riches of the Gentiles; how much more their fulness?” (11-12)
“For if the casting away of them [Israel] be the reconciling of the world [Gentiles], what shall the receiving of them be, but life from the dead?” (15)
“As concerning the gospel, they [Israel] are enemies for your [the Gentiles who believe] sakes: but as touching the election, they are beloved for the father's sakes. (28)
The whole analogy of the tree and the branches also demands this interpretation. The natural branches are the Jews; the grafted-in branches are the Gentiles. Israel here is ethnic Isreal.
Again, we must not forget that all of chapters 9-11 deal with God’s purposes concerning the Jewish people. Paul identifies himself with them, as being one of them at the beginning of chapters 9 and 11 (9:3; 11:1). An Israelite is one who is “of the seed of Abraham,” which Paul in terms of himself goes on to further clarify as “of the tribe of Benjamin.” There is no other way to take this than to mean that Paul is referring to Israel as being defined by physical descent from Abraham.
God is not through with ethnic Israel.
I think it is especially relevant for us to consider this today, especially in our times when there is rising antisemitism in the West. And now it is not only coming from the Left, but increasingly it is coming from parts of the Right. The kinds of conspiracy theories and language that the Nazis used to stir up hatred against the Jews in pre-World War 2 Germany are now being repurposed among some so-called conservatives. This is a real problem. Anyone who stirs people up to hate the Jews because they are Jews is setting themselves up against God and his purpose. We should not be against the Jewish people. We should pray for them, pray for their salvation, and ask God to do what he has promised here. We should love the Jewish people. That does not mean that we have to rubber stamp everything the modern Jewish state does. That’s not what “Israel” means here, either. Israel in Romans 11 is ethnic Isreal, not the modern Jewish state. At the same time, it seems to me that a lot of the venom which is aimed at the Jewish state is aimed at it precisely because it is peopled by the Jews. Let’s not be guilty of that. Romans 11 should prevent us from going anywhere near the sin that is antisemitism.
With that being said, there is a lot of instruction and encouragement here in these verses, not only with respect to the Jewish people as such, but what it has to say about God’s saving purposes in the midst of widespread apostasy. That was not only relevant in Paul’s day; it’s relevant in ours, as we will see.
What the person of Paul says about Israel’s future
Paul says that he himself is proof that God is not done with Israel. Paul was the apostle to the Gentiles (cf. 11:13; 15:16), but God did not send a Gentile to Gentiles. He sent a Jew. And not just any Jew, but, as Paul himself puts it to the Philippians, “an Hebrew of the Hebrews” (Phil. 3:5). So he says, as proof of the negative answer given to the question, “Hath God cast away his people?” – “For I also am an Israelite, of the seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin” (1).
In fact, all the apostles were Jews. The authors of the books of the Bible were predominantly, if not entirely, Jewish. It’s probable that Luke was a Gentile, but with that one exception, every other author of a Biblical book, whether Old Testament or New, were Jews. The very foundation of the church in terms of its authoritative Scripture, is Jewish. Our Savior is Jewish, and Jesus did not shed his Jewishness once he rose from the dead and ascended into heaven. The Christian religion is a Jewish religion. Let’s not forget that, and Paul is reminding us of that fact by bringing up himself as an example of a Jewish Christian, even as many of his kinsmen wanted nothing to do with the faith.
What the purpose of God says about Israel’s future
The next thing Paul says to justify his claim that God is not done with ethnic Israel is here at the beginning of verse 2: “God hath not cast away his people which he foreknew.”
Now we have noted elsewhere, when it refers to something God does, foreknowledge is equivalent to election. In Romans 8, Paul says that those whom God foreknew, he predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son (29). That is to say, those whom God chose and elected in Christ before the foundation of the world, he predestined to be conformed to his Son. So here: but the foreknowledge here is not election to salvation, but the election of the nation of Israel. In chapter 9, Paul distinguished between the election of the nation and the election of individuals (9:6-13). The former is an election to a historical role for the nation which gave them many privileges; the latter is an election to salvation for individuals in that nation which gives them eternal life. Here, in 11:2, Paul is again referring to the election of the nation in terms of God’s foreknowledge of them. This clearly does not mean that God distinguished the nation of Israel by merely knowing about them, for this is true of all nations. This foreknowledge is another way of referring to God’s special election of Israel, distinguishing them and setting them apart from the Gentile nations, giving them the Scriptures and teaching them true worship.
The point that Paul is making here is that God, who has thus signally favored Israel, is not one to easily take back his favors. As Paul will put it at the end of this chapter, “As concerning the gospel, they are enemies for your sakes: but as touching the election, they are beloved for the father's sakes. For the gifts and calling of God are without repentance” (28-29). God did not choose Israel simply to through them away; that is Paul’s argument. That is not who God is and that is not how he operates. The fact that he has foreknown Israel, chosen the nation and set them apart, means that God is not going to simply walk away from them and be done with them. They are still the natural branches (24) and one day God will graft them back onto the tree of his covenant people.
No other nation has this kind of distinction, not the United States, not Great Britian, not Russia, nor China, nor any other nation. No other people group have been favored the way God has favored the Jewish people. Let us remember that. Let us not forget that. You don’t have to be a dispensationalist (I’m not) to affirm such a thing. You simply have to believe what the Bible says. And we should certainly do that.
What past history says about Israel’s future
This is where Paul will camp out in terms of his main argument supporting his answer that God will not abandon Israel. He reminds us of something that happened all the way back in the days of Elijah, during the reign of king Ahab, the infamous ninth-century B.C. ruler of the northern kingdom of Israel. Now we have already pointed this out several times in our exposition of Romans 9 and 10, but Paul again makes a point regarding the present and the future by pointing us to God’s ways in the past. This only works if God is consistent, and he is. The way he has worked in the past is the way we should expect him to work in the future. Not of course in every detail, and, yes, there are certain unrepeatable events in the past as well (creation, exodus, the cross). But since God is unchanging and immutable in his person and purposes, we should expect his ways in the past to be reduplicated in the future. This gives Paul the reason to argue the way he now does.
What does he say? “Wot [know] ye not what the scripture saith of Elias? how he maketh intercession to God against Israel saying, Lord, they have killed thy prophets, and digged down thine altars; and I am left alone, and they seek my life” (2-3). This is from the nineteenth chapter of 1 Kings, verse 10. It is Elijah’s words of complaint to God. He was incredibly depressed, for despite the fact that he had won the contest with the prophets of Baal (an 850-1 contest), and fire from heaven had literally fallen, yet wickedness was still on the throne, and his life was now being threatened by Ahab’s queen, the witch Jezabel. Elijah was clearly thinking that if such an event didn’t turn the tide, then what would? He wanted to give up. He was done with the people of Israel. After all, they killed the true prophets of God, abandoned his worship, and he was the only one left. At least, that is what he sincerely thought. No one was left! What was there to salvage? Nothing! And so he wanted God to end his life and take him home, for there was nothing left for him to do.
Paul brings that up probably because he was tempted to adopt the Elijah-syndrome. After all, as these chapters here in Romans painfully document, most Jews didn’t want to hear or believe in the gospel. They had mostly rejected it, and violently so. But Paul had learned the lesson of Elijah. What was that answer? It was the answer of God to him: “But what saith the answer of God unto him? I have reserved to myself seven thousand men, who have not bowed the knee to the image of Baal” (4). Elijah thought he was the only one left; God let him in on the fact that not only was he not the only one, but that there were seven thousand others who had refused to worship Baal and had continued to faithfully worship the true God of Israel. God was at work in ways that Elijah didn’t know or couldn’t understand.
Notice the conclusion that the apostle draws from this: “Even so then at this present time also there is a remnant according to the election of grace” (5). Now just as in chapter 9, Paul differentiated between the election of the nation to temporal privileges and the election of individuals to salvation, Paul does the same thing here. The foreknowledge in verse 2 refers to the election of the nation, the special status that God gave it in the history of redemption. But here in verse 5 this clearly refers to the election of individuals within the nation of Israel – the seven thousand who still worshiped the true God. Paul is basically saying that this has always been the case. “They are not all Israel which are of Israel.” And that principle didn’t stop at the cross. It carries on, according to Paul. He’s an example of this. And there were other Jews as well who were examples of this in his own day. In fact, “many thousands of Jews there are which believe” (Acts 21:20), as the elders of the church in Jerusalem informed Paul. God was not done with the people of Israel. He still had elect among them.
And Paul can’t help but elaborate on this. Why were these Jews saved? It wasn’t because they kept the law. It wasn’t because they were the descendants of Abraham. It wasn’t because they were better than others. It was solely and entirely because of the free grace of God in Christ. The election by which they were chosen to salvation was an “election of grace.” Paul goes on: “And if by grace, then is it no more of works: otherwise grace is no more grace. But if it be of works, then it is no more grace: otherwise work is no more work” (6). Election is of grace, not works. It is not based on foreseen works of any kind. Otherwise, grace would not be grace. We must never forget this
And let’s not forget how grace comes. Yes, election is of grace. But it can only be by grace because God the Father chose us in Christ (Eph. 1:4). We are justified freely by his grace which is given to us in Christ Jesus (Rom. 3:24). How so? Because Christ paid the debt that the elect owed. It comes freely to those who believe, but it came at great cost to God. “He that spared not his own Son, how shall he not also with him freely give us all things?” (Rom. 8:32). “For you know the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, that though he was rich, yet for our sakes he became poor, that ye through his poverty might become rich” (2 Cor. 8:9). What we receive freely by faith Christ purchased at an infinite cost with his life. The gospel is not that God saves irrespective of justice or without an atonement for sin. The holiness of God demands that we cannot be saved apart from an atonement for our sins. The gospel is that we don’t have to make an atonement; Christ is our atonement and those who believe on him receive it by grace apart from works of any kind. Have you, my friend, received the atonement through faith?
Now, banking on the assumption that Paul employs here, that God’s ways are consistent across time, we can safely and properly apply this to our day as well, not only as it respects the Jews, but this has lessons for the church today as well. After all, the Gentiles have been grafted into the tree of God’s covenant people, just as Israel was in times past.
But before we do this, let’s not forget that what Paul says here in verse 5 is true today: “even so then at this present time” – even now, two thousand years later – “there is a remnant” among the Jews “according to the election of grace.” The church has never been exclusively Gentile, and the descendants of Abraham have continued to contribute to the growth of the church and the advance of God’s kingdom. Like Elijah, we may not see all the ways this is happening. But let’s not forget that just because we cannot see it doesn’t mean it’s not happening.
Let me give you an example of this in our own day. Many of you know about John MacArthur, the late pastor of Grace Community Church in the LA area, who was one of the ablest and most influential preachers and expositors of Scripture in our day. What you may not know is that one of the formative influences on his life as a minister of the word of God was the dean of the seminary he attended. His name was Charles Feinberg, and he was a Jew. Here is what Dr. MacArthur said about him:
“The dean of the seminary I attended was Dr. Charles Feinberg, one of the most brilliant and respected men I have ever known. He was Jewish, and after studying for 14 years to be a rabbi, he was converted to Christ. He knew more than thirty languages. He even told me once that he taught himself Dutch because he wanted to read Dutch Reformed theology. He also read through the Bible four times every year. Needless to say, he was exceptional and intense. We were all rightfully in awe of him, and I loved him at the same time.”
MacArthur tells the story that as a student in seminary, he was given the task of preaching on 2 Samuel 7 in front of a panel of teachers, one of whom was Dr. Feinberg. MacArthur was called into his office after the sermon, only to hear the words, “You missed the point of the passage!” It had a profound impact on MacArthur, and he never forgot the lesson. He wrote, “To this day, when I come to the text each week and begin to study its richness and depth, I can still hear Dr. Feinberg’s heartfelt admonition ringing in my ears. If you don’t have the meaning of Scripture, you do not have the Word of God at all. If you miss the true sense of what God has said, you are not actually preaching God’s Word! That reality has compelled me for nearly 40 years of preaching.” The church may never know just how much we owe to that one critique by a Jewish follower of Jesus of John MacArthur. Thank God for modern day Pauls!
What Lessons can we learn from this?
There are a number of lessons we can learn from this passage. Let me just briefly outline some of them for you. They are not in any particular order of importance, but I’m just giving them to you as they came to me.
1. The prevalence of evil and ignorance is no proof that God is not working for the good of his kingdom and cause in this world. The fact of the matter is that the level of apostasy in Israel in the ninth century B.C. that Paul refers to here is hard for us to imagine. The idolatry, the violence, the blatant disregard for God’s law, the persecution of his true followers, the immorality were not incidental features of that society, but were features of it from the top to the bottom. Baal worship was the predominant religion in a nation that was supposed to be worshiping Yahweh. And yet, even though Elijah couldn’t see it – all he could see were the bad things – God was at work. Even so today, we are living in a morally bankrupt society. Our society justifies the killing of infants in the womb, the mutilating of children who have become gender-confused in a society that is out of its mind, defends a woman who killed her own children, exalts politicians who claim to be Christian but deny its fundamental teachings and scolds and persecutes those who proclaim them and live by them. The church is weak and shallow, untethered to the word of God in his doctrines and practices. Its pastors practice at being entrepreneurs instead of being holy men of God. There is much reason to look around us and despair. But, friends, God is at work. We can be sure of that. He is at work in this world. He is still building and protecting his church and his people. He is still regenerating his elect and bringing them to faith in Christ. Let’s not forget that lesson.
2. Despise not the day of small things. This is what God said to Israel in a day of rebuilding the temple. The rebuilt temple was not as grand as Solomon’s temple. But it was God’s temple and God was pleased. That is what matters: not the size of things but the faithfulness of God’s people. Yes, it is true that there were seven thousand men who did not bow the knee to the image of Baal. But seven thousand in an entire nation is not a lot! That’s a very small minority. It was, as Paul puts it, a remnant. But you know what? God works through remnants. Let’s not think that unless the church does something big, it does nothing at all. That is not true. Don’t despise the day of small things, whether in your own life, or in the church. Let’s not forget that lesson.
3. We don’t know everything God is doing around us. Elijah didn’t know, and we don’t either. This lesson was driven home to me when I recently reread the biography of A. W. Pink by Iain Murray. He notes that Pink was relatively unaware of big things that were happening in his day. He was unaware, for example, of the ministry of Lloyd-Jones which was going on in the very land where Pink lived. Now part of this was Pink’s own fault. Like Elijah, he had too negative a view of the church in his time and he ended up withdrawing himself from any kind of church fellowship of any kind. Pink thought that everything was so bad people probably needed to start over. But what he didn’t know is that God was going to use his own writings to cause a resurgence of interest in the very doctrines that he spent his whole life writing and caring about: God’s sovereignty in salvation, the importance of holiness in the Christian life, and the necessity for Bible-based preaching and church life. After he died, he writings were gathered from the magazine he published, collected, and put into books and disseminated all over the globe. I myself credit (under God) my conversion to Pink’s book The Sovereignty of God. He never saw this, and in fact couldn’t, could he? So, my friend, don’t judge God by what you can see. Let’s not forget that lesson.
4. What God is doing, he is doing through the remnant that does not bow the knee to the image of Baal. Who are the elect? They are the men and women who refuse to bow their knees to the image of Baal. They are the men and women who refuse to do what the culture expects them to do when that thing is contrary to God’s word. They are counter-cultural people. We must not think that election by grace gives us a free ride to live anyway we want to and then expect to go to heaven. The wicked will not go to heaven because grace not only delivers us from the guilt of our sins, it also delivers us from the grip of our sins. Grace does not leave a person in the state in which it finds him or her. The Baal worshippers – who were just doing what everyone else was doing – were not among the elect. It was the people who at the risk of their own lives remained faithful to the true God who were among the elect. The Baal worshipers of today, who forsake the word of God for their own ideas and feelings, who join the society in celebrating sin, cannot be said to be among the elect if they do not repent. Though holiness does not make us elect, it does manifest us to be elect. God chose us, Paul says, to be holy (Eph. 1:4). Let us not forget that lesson.
All of this together ought to encourage us. Paul must have been encouraged by the fact that, despite widespread Jewish unbelief and resistance to the gospel, God was not finished with them. This probably explains why he kept going back to the synagogues. Even so, brethren, let’s be encouraged by the fact that, though we cannot claim for the US what Paul claims for Israel, we can claim it for the church. God will always have his faithful remnant. God is always at work, advancing his cause and extending his kingdom into the next generation. So brothers and sisters, let be encouraged and let’s be faithful. Don’t bow the knee to the image of Baal!

Comments
Post a Comment